Sunday 17 April 2011

Rpeh for Admin - for real!

I can only assume there is a spy in UESP Watch Towers, because it's the only way Krusty could have timed his nomination of rpeh for Admin precisely after I went away for a week.

Of course we don't need to do any diffs for this story because it's obvious that there will be loads of editors supporting the nomination but that Rawtwat the Vicious and Elliot the Obnoxiously Thick will oppose it, right? Eh? What's that? Really? Seriously?!?! Okay, let's do this properly then.

Things started off as predicted, with Alpha Kenny Buddy, Pwnageincarnate, Legoless and Corevette789 all voting "Yay" before rpeh had even posted his responses. Next came Lucius Tarquinius Superbus, then rpeh added a whole extra load of crap, then comes the first opposition: Wrye.

It's been so long since Wrye has shown his face that I couldn't remember much about him, except that he was a bit of a pompous twat at times. I had a murky memory of him even managing to annoy the usually unflappable Timenn, and eventually found the debate here. The next memory refresher was to look at his edit distribution, which made my eyebrows go up along way.  40% of his edits are about promoting his modding projects in the Tes3Mod and Tes4Mod namespaces. Another 14% has him arguing in UESPWiki space, 17% in User space, and after that, there's almost nothing. Now I see why rpeh wanted regular admin votes - this guy is treating the wiki like his own private website.

Anyway. After nice, subtle dig from rpeh, we have several increasingly desperate attempts from Wrye to justify his vote interspersed with several people telling him he's a moron. Eventually we come to our second Oppose vote, and it's from Whining Little Bitch fully living up to his name, in a post demolished by rpeh a little later.

The next odd vote is from DKong27, who I had firmly in the "Support" camp, but who voted "Neutral", making the accurate point that rpeh does tend to make enemies, but it's this vote that really made me swear in disbelief. Elliot voted to support rpeh's RfA. Let me repeat that: Elliot voted to support rpeh's RfA. In a well-written and thoughtful post, Elliot takes a brief look at their history, moves on, and expresses some hopes and thoughts for the future. I might have to change his name if he keeps making posts like this one.

With the vote currently at 17-2, and a full week already gone, it's only a matter of time before UESP has a new admin. True, Daveh might decide not to listen to the community's suggestion, but since we know he's already given rpeh server access, I can't see that being a problem.

Let's hope he has learned from the mistakes of the past and is not doomed to repeat them.

9 comments:

  1. Neural Tempest is from Canada, has advanced editing skills, edits templates, and makes a long post on policy two weeks after his first edit. Joram 2?

    The only thing is it's /too/ obvious if it's him.

    ReplyDelete
  2. To judge from his messages elsewhere, I think Whiny Little Bitch / RobinHood70 / Joram has finally disappeared. It's a bit of a pity, but at least we won't have to suffer the interminable moaning any more.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Looks like after all of the drama from UESP has disappeared, there's not much to report on, huh Tiber?

    2 months and no poast...

    ReplyDelete
  4. Right. All quiet on the UESP front. Suits me fine.

    ReplyDelete
  5. AlthoughIo used to love this blog before I joined usep, now that I'm an active editor and a userspace patroller I have to admit I'm kinda glad you stopped when you did. It's not as funny when the shoe is on the other foot to be honest, and I don't want a nasty nickname.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I haven't stopped... I'm just resting.

    ReplyDelete
  7. And there's never any real drama anymore either

    ReplyDelete
  8. Well, SerCenKing and AKB both returned last night, Rigas has been popping in and out, and Kalis Agea looks set to become a patroller with 5 support votes and no opposes (Which I'm happy about because Kalis is sound and a fab editor so he deserves it). Unfortunately, the most interesting thing to happen yesterday was Honda removing a warning from his talk page and getting told off for it. Its eerily quiet on uesp, but I love it there anyway. There, I practically wrote your blog for you!

    ReplyDelete